Stay up-to-date with the antiques world

By subscribing, you are agreeing to the privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Barnebys

Barnebys HQ

Brahegatan 10
BOX 5038
114 37 Stockholm

Company

  • About Us
  • Join Barnebys
  • Our Partners
  • Press
  • Career

Explore More

  • Barnepedia
  • Buying / Selling at auction
  • Auction Houses / Dealers / Galleries

Support

  • FAQ
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy and Cookies policy
  • Contact us
  • Barnebys Group AB
  • Barnebys.se
  • Barnebys.com
  • Barnebys.co.uk
  • Barnebys.de
  • Barnebys.fr
  • Barnebys.es
  • Barnebys.it
  • Barnebys.hk
  • All auction items
  • Categories
  • Auction results
  • Magazine
  • Ancient Art
  • Arts & Graphics
  • Asian Art
  • Books, Maps & Manuscripts
  • Carpets, Rugs & Textile
  • Coins & Banknotes
  • Contemporary Art
  • Ethnographical
  • Fashion & Vintage
  • Folk Art
  • Furniture, Design & Mirrors
  • Glass
  • Jewellery & Gems
  • Lighting
  • Medals, Arms & Armour
  • Miscellaneous
  • Music & Musical Instruments
  • Nautica, Technica & Optic
  • Photographs
  • Porcelain & Pottery
  • Postcards & Stamps
  • Sculptures
  • Silver & Gold
  • Sports & Leisure
  • Tin & Metals
  • Toys & Collectables
  • Vehicles
  • Watches & Clocks
  • Wine & Spirits
  • Works of art
  • All auction items
  • Auction results
  • Magazine
  • Get a valuation
  • Auction system

Barnebys Magazine

LatestEditor's picksTopics
Magazine/Painting/Is this £1,300 Painting by Caravaggio?

Is this £1,300 Painting by Caravaggio?

The auction of a painting originally attributed to José de Ribera was halted by the Spanish Minister of Culture because experts said it could be a Caravaggio.

14 April 2021Gritta von Toll
Is this painting a work from the environment of José de Ribera or was it painted by Caravaggio? Photo © Ansorena

Is this painting a work from the environment of José de Ribera or was it painted by Caravaggio? Photo © Ansorena

Last week, a painting with the subject of Ecce Homo (Jesus crowned with thorns) attributed to the circle of José de Ribera was headed to auction, but a few hours before the auction, the Spanish government intervened to block the sale of the work. 

This 111 x 86 cm oil painting, estimated at €1,500 euros (£1,300), caught the attention of experts at the Prado Museum, who said in a report that it could be a work of Caravaggio. If their hypothesis is confirmed, the value of the painting could reach €100 to 150 million (£87-130 mil). The Spanish government has declared the work 'un-exportable' and wishes to carry out in-depth analyses to determine the author. 

“Considering how quickly all of this has happened, we now need a thorough technical and scientific investigation into the painting in question. We have to discuss whether the attribution to Caravaggio is plausible and can be scientifically accepted," said José Manuel Rodríguez Uribes, spokesperson for the Spanish Ministry of Culture.

Christ with his crown of thorns before the Crucifixion. Photo © Ansorena

According to the Italian daily La Repubblica, Caravaggio had painted an Ecce Homo for Cardinal Massimo Massimi in 1605 in Rome. A painting on the same theme, the description of which corresponds to the painting for sale at Ansorena, was inventoried in 1631 in the collection of the Spanish Ambassador to the Holy See, Juan de Lezcano, before appearing in 1657 in Naples in the collection of García de Avellaneda y Haro, Count of Castrillo and Viceroy of Naples. Both works may have left Italy for Spain with their owner in 1659.

See also: Top 10 Rediscovered Masterpieces

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571-1610) is one of the most important painters of the early Baroque period, who developed the technique of chiaroscuro. His style was picked up, imitated and developed by many other painters, and called 'Caravaggism'.

One of his followers was José de Ribera (1591-1652), a painter born in Spain who spent most of his life in Italy, where he first studied Caravaggio's work in Rome before moving to go to Naples to imitate, develop and transmit this style to his students.

Find the latest art world news on Barnebys Magazine

caravaggioart auctionpainting

Subscribe to Barnebys Magazine

By subscribing, you are agreeing to the privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the author

Gritta von Toll

Gritta von Toll is the German Editor at Barnebys Magazine. She completed studies in pre- and early history and archaeology, and since 2015, after a short detour into the world of advertising, she has worked at Barnebys, where she immerses herself in art history in order to bring bygone epochs closer to today's readers.

Read more from this author
Gritta von Toll

Bring your auction to collectors worldwide!