Stay up-to-date with the antiques world

By subscribing, you are agreeing to the privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Barnebys

Barnebys HQ

Brahegatan 10
BOX 5038
114 37 Stockholm

Company

  • About Us
  • Join Barnebys
  • Our Partners
  • Press
  • Career

Explore More

  • Barnepedia
  • Buying / Selling at auction
  • Auction Houses / Dealers / Galleries

Support

  • FAQ
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy and Cookies policy
  • Contact us
  • Barnebys Group AB
  • Barnebys.se
  • Barnebys.com
  • Barnebys.co.uk
  • Barnebys.de
  • Barnebys.fr
  • Barnebys.es
  • Barnebys.it
  • Barnebys.hk
  • All auction items
  • Categories
  • Auction results
  • Magazine
  • Ancient Art
  • Arts & Graphics
  • Asian Art
  • Books, Maps & Manuscripts
  • Carpets, Rugs & Textile
  • Coins & Banknotes
  • Contemporary Art
  • Ethnographical
  • Fashion & Vintage
  • Folk Art
  • Furniture, Design & Mirrors
  • Glass
  • Jewellery & Gems
  • Lighting
  • Medals, Arms & Armour
  • Miscellaneous
  • Music & Musical Instruments
  • Nautica, Technica & Optic
  • Photographs
  • Porcelain & Pottery
  • Postcards & Stamps
  • Sculptures
  • Silver & Gold
  • Sports & Leisure
  • Tin & Metals
  • Toys & Collectables
  • Vehicles
  • Watches & Clocks
  • Wine & Spirits
  • Works of art
  • All auction items
  • Auction results
  • Magazine
  • Get a valuation
  • Auction system

Barnebys Magazine

LatestEditor's picksTopics
Magazine/Jewellery & Gems/Is the Hope Diamond Really Cursed?

Is the Hope Diamond Really Cursed?

The world's most famous diamond is rumoured to bring misfortune to its illustrious owners, from kings to heiresses. Here we look back on its spellbinding history.

6 August 2020Kira Reinke
Mrs. Thomas Phipps wears the world-famous Hope Diamond, lent to her by jeweller Harry Winston, at the Bal de Tete in New York, Nov. 15, 1949. Photo Bettmann/Getty Images

Mrs. Thomas Phipps wears the world-famous Hope Diamond, lent to her by jeweller Harry Winston, at the Bal de Tete in New York, Nov. 15, 1949. Photo Bettmann/Getty Images

The malevolent influence that has for centuries dogged with discord and disaster the owners of the famous Hope diamond has started again.

The fantastic history of the Hope Diamond begins over one billion years ago, when it was formed in the Earth, created by the intense bonds between carbon atoms and the inclusion of boron atoms, which contribute to the rare deep blue-violet shade. The details of the diamond's extraction are murky, but the stone first appeared on record in 1666, owned by gem merchant Jean-Baptiste Tavernier in Paris. He claimed that the Tavernier Blue, the 112-carat uncut diamond, was from the Kollur mine in India, where many of the world's most valuable diamonds are from. It is unclear how Tavernier acquired the diamond, but salacious theories include stealing it from a temple of a Hindu goddess, who cursed the gem.

Nicolas de Largillière, 'Portait of Jean-Baptiste Tavernier', 1700, oil on canvas. Photo public domain

See also: Barnebys’ Guide to Diamonds

Two years later, in 1668, he sold the Tavernier Blue, along with 25 other diamonds, to King Louis XIV, who had the diamond recut by the court jeweller into a 67-carat stone, renamed the French Blue. It was set in gold and suspended by a ribbon to be worn around the King's neck during official ceremonies.

This gouache of King Louis XV's Golden Fleece of the Colored Adornment, based on information about the piece and its gems gleaned from this study, was created in 2008 by Pascal Monney, Geneva, Switzerland. Image in the public domain from Francois Farges via Researchgate

See also: Crown Jewels: 5 Times Royal Jewellery Made Auction Headlines

In 1749, Louis XV, the king's great grandson, inherited the stone and had it reset into an elaborate brooch for the Order of the Golden Fleece, a Catholic order. The extravagant piece included red, yellow and white diamonds which culminated in the French blue, under which was a yellow sheep of diamonds.

Antoine-François Callet, 'Louis XVI, King of France and Navarre', 1789, oil on canvas. Photo public domain

The stone remained in the medal of the Golden Fleece until the French Revolution. On 11 September 1792, the royal family, including King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, was imprisoned and the French Royal Treasury raided, resulting in the disappearance of all of the Crown Jewels. A year later, the King and Queen were guillotined.

The French Blue reappeared in London in 1812, but had been cut down to 45 carats and was then owned by Thomas Eliason, a diamond merchant. Some believe it was then sold to King George IV, the portly and extravagant ruler whose private life was riddled with addiction, severe health problems, massive debts and an estranged marriage. After his death in 1830, the diamond was privately resold.

See also: Tiffany: King of Diamonds

Within a few years, the diamond was purchased by prominent British banker Thomas Hope, and in 1839 was recorded in the estate of his brother, Henry Philip Hope. Here is where the diamond got its enduring moniker of the 'Hope' Diamond. Thomas Hope's son, Henry Thomas Hope, inherited the diamond after the death of his uncle, and lent it to expositions in London and Paris in the 1850s. Later it passed to his wife, Adele, after his death, and later his grandson, Lord Henry Francis Hope, the Duke of Newcastle.

Francis Pelham-Clinton-Hope, 8th Duke of Newcastle, who was the last of the Hope family to own the Hope Diamond. Photo public domain

In 1894, Lord Francis met the woman who would lead to his undoing, the beautiful May Yohé, an American concert singer. He married her that year and spent lavishly on her, incurring heavy debts. By 1901, he was finally allowed by the courts to sell the diamond, but his marriage had crumbled and May left him for another man.

See also: The World's 10 Most Expensive Diamonds

The diamond was sold for £29,000 (£2.3 million in today's money) to a London jeweller, who resold it to another jeweller, Simon Frankel, for $250,000 (£5.3 million today). Frankel brought the diamond to New York in 1902. After the Depression of 1907, Frankel had financial problems and had to sell the diamond to a wealthy Turk, Sem Habib, who was believed to be a front for the Turkish Sultan Abdul Hamid II. The mania around the diamond increased in 1908 when the Washington Post published an article 'Hope Diamond Has Brought Trouble To All Who Have Owned It', though many of the tales of murder, suicide, imprisonment and financial ruin were largely anecdotal. A year later, however, the Sultan was deposed and the diamond was sold by Sem Habib in Paris.

Heiress Evalyn Walsh McLean wearing the Hope Diamond in 1914. Photo public domain

The Hope Diamond was acquired by Pierre Cartier in 1910, who presented the storied stone to Evalyn Walsh McLean, a wealthy heiress and socialite in Washington, DC. Evalyn and her husband, Ned, bought the necklace in 1911 for $300,000 (about £6.2 million today), although McLean's family would warn her to sell it back because of the alleged curse. The New York Times published a rebuttal in 1911 to the Post's earlier article to explain that most of the stories were fabricated to add publicity to the diamond and increase its price.

See also: The 9 Most Popular Jewellery Brands

Cartier had reset the stone into a headpiece, but McLean later had him convert it into the traditional diamond necklace setting, with 16 white diamonds encircling the blue diamond and a necklace of 45 white diamonds. She frequently wore the diamond necklace at social events at her estate in Washington, DC and is even rumoured to have hung it around her dog's neck. It was guarded by three security detectives and kept in a locked vault every night.

Mrs. Thomas Phipps wears the world-famous Hope Diamond, lent to her by jeweller Harry Winston, at the Bal de Tete in New York, Nov. 15, 1949. Photo Bettmann/Getty Images

See also: Fabergé Eggs: 8 Little Known Facts

However, misfortune did come to the McLeans. In 1919, their young son was hit by a car and killed, and they divorced in 1932. Ned, who was the publisher of the Washington Post, was beset by mental illness and died in 1942. Evelyn died later in 1947 of pneumonia, and the diamond was sold from her estate to Harry Winston in 1949, along with her other massive diamonds, including the Star of the East, Star of the South and the McLean Diamond. Winston toured the Hope Diamond around the US for a decade, before agreeing to donate it to the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History in Washington, DC in 1958.

The package delivering the Hope diamond from Harry Winston to the Smithsonian museum in Washington, DC. Photo public domain

The diamond was sent from Winston's New York headquarters to the museum in a plain brown paper package, insured for then $1 million. It became the main attraction for the museum and has rarely been lent out, only leaving the Smithsonian four brief times in the past 62 years. Although the Hope Diamond has been placed in different settings at times, it is still exhibited in the same Cartier necklace that Evalyn Walsh wore.

The Hope diamond with 45.52 carats in the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C. on January 13, 2012. Photo by Marvin Joseph/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Today, the diamond is said to be worth $250-350 million (£190-265 mil), and although its fascinating history has its share of disaster, many of its more sordid tales have never been proven and were likely concocted to incite public interest in the gem. A curator at the Smithsonian stated the Hope diamond has only brought record attendance to the museum, so perhaps the curse, if there ever was one, is now broken.

Discover more articles with Barnebys Magazine

hope diamonddiamondjewelroyaljewellery

Subscribe to Barnebys Magazine

By subscribing, you are agreeing to the privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the author

Kira Reinke

Kira Reinke is the US Editor at Barnebys Magazine. She majored in English and Art History at St. Olaf College and has a master's degree in Journalism from Columbia University. Prior to working at Barnebys, she worked in editorial at a travel agency. Her interests focus on fine art, design, and fashion on the auction market, and she enjoys attending auction previews, museum exhibits, and gallery openings in New York.

Read more from this author
Kira Reinke

Explore related articles

Replica of the Crown of Queen Elizabeth, The Queen Mother, with a replica of the Koh-I-Noor diamond at Royal Coster Diamonds. Photo by AlinavdMeulen - Own work (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en) (Detail).
Jewellery & Gems

10 Historical Diamonds You Should Know

Finding 'witch marks' was part of a witch trial, as depicted by the American painter Tompkins Harrison Matteson in 1853. He was probably inspired by the famous witch trials that took place in Salem, Massachusetts, in 1692/93. Photo in the public domain (detail)
Books

Malleus Maleficarum: a Guide to Witchcraft

The 6 Nobel Prize for Literature laureates. Details of the photos in the article.
Books

6 Women Who Have Won the Nobel Prize in Literature

Discover similar items at auction

Vintage "Skull and Bones" Diamond Ring

Vintage "Skull and Bones" Diamond Ring

US
New Orleans Auctions Galleries
Details
Queen Victoria Silver Diamond Jubilee Medal

Queen Victoria Silver Diamond Jubilee Medal

US
New Orleans Auctions Galleries
Details
Diamond Bracelet

Diamond Bracelet

US
Charlton Hall
Details
Diamond Necklace

Diamond Necklace

US
Charlton Hall
Details
Diamond Brooch

Diamond Brooch

US
Charlton Hall
Details
Platinum & Diamond Brooch

Platinum & Diamond Brooch

US
Revere Auctions
Details

Bring your auction to collectors worldwide!